|Year : 2013 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 96-105
Digital method for lip print analysis: A New approach
Rachana V Prabhu1, Ajit Dinkar2, Vishnudas Prabhu3
1 Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Yenepoya Dental College, Yenepoya University, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
2 Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Goa Dental College and Hospital, Bambolim, Goa, India
3 Department of Oral Pathology, Yenepoya Dental College, Yenepoya University, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
|Date of Web Publication||11-Oct-2013|
Rachana V Prabhu
Yenepoya Dental College, Yenepoya University, Nithyananda Nagar Post, Deralakatte, Mangalore - 575018, Karnataka
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Aim: To evaluate the uniqueness and to define a standard method for the analysis of lip prints. Materials and Methods: Lip prints of 100 students were taken using Scotch tape without any distortion. These prints were then scanned for the digital analysis. Using Adobe Photoshop 7 software an attempt was made to trace each and every line using Suzuki and Tsuchihashi's classification. Weighted value scoring system was used to check for the uniqueness of the lip prints. Results: No two lip prints had exactly matching scores in all four Quadrants. No statistically significant difference was found in the change of pattern in lip print images collected after 12 months from the same individual. With digital analysis, up to 15 lines were traceable in 66%, 71%, 52% and 51% of Quadrant I, II, III and IV respectively. Conclusion: Lip prints are unique to an individual. The digital method of analyzing lip print images serves better visualization, ease in identification and recording of the lip print pattern. Weighted Value Scoring system can be considered as a standard method for determining the uniqueness of the lip prints.
Keywords: Cheiloscopy, digital analysis, lip prints, lip score, weighted value
|How to cite this article:|
Prabhu RV, Dinkar A, Prabhu V. Digital method for lip print analysis: A New approach. J Forensic Dent Sci 2013;5:96-105
|How to cite this URL:|
Prabhu RV, Dinkar A, Prabhu V. Digital method for lip print analysis: A New approach. J Forensic Dent Sci [serial online] 2013 [cited 2020 Jan 26];5:96-105. Available from: http://www.jfds.org/text.asp?2013/5/2/96/119772
| Introduction|| |
Identification is a matter of paramount importance in any crime investigation. Even though DNA and fingerprints are the time-tested methods, these evidences are not always available at the investigation sites. In such circumstances, it is necessary to apply different and less-known techniques. A new area of investigation in the detection of crime is the use of wrinkles on the lips. Cheiloscopy (Quiloscopy) is a method of identification of a person based on characteristic arrangement of lines appearing on the red part of lips. Very little has been said or written about the application of lip prints in these days of advanced scientific crime detection. In view of the need of forensic dental services in the different parts of our country it was found necessary to do research on the use of lip prints for person identification. It was therefore decided to carry out a pilot study to evaluate the uniqueness of the lip prints and their stability over a period of time. The authors have introduced the Weighted Value Scoring system for the first time to calculate the LIP SCORE for each lip in an intention to settle once and for all the question of the uniqueness of the lip print. It was felt that such a study would prevent one of the most important forms of evidence from being overlooked.
The studies done so far ,,,,,,,, depended on the manual method for the lip print analysis which has its own demerits. The information that is lacking in the research of cheiloscopy is an accurate methodology for lip print collection and a standard method for its analysis. The present study was also aimed to develop an ideal methodology for lip print collection that provides minimal distortion and greater clarity of the image. The study has been designed to carry out the analysis of the lip prints using computer software program, 'Adobe Photoshop 7.0' for the first time.
| Materials and methods|| |
A pilot study was conducted at the Oral Medicine, Diagnosis, and Radiology Department of the Goa Dental College and Hospital, Bambolim, Goa - 403 202, India. The study comprised 100 subjects selected from amongst the students of the Goa Dental College and Hospital, Bambolim, Goa, India, whose ages ranged between 19 to 28 years. Subjects with inflammation, ulcers, trauma, congenital developmental defects and malformation, deformity and surgical scars (e.g. operation for cleft lip) and other abnormalities of lips were excluded because of their unsuitability for this investigation either because the defect itself was enough for identification or the clinical condition precluded from enrolling the individual in this study. Subjects with allergy to cosmetics (lipstick) were also excluded from the study. Informed consent of the subjects was taken and they were explained that they would be a part of a Research Program wherein cosmetics had to be used for recording the lip prints. The object being the human mouth, special attention was paid to the cleanliness and hygiene while recording the lip prints by giving a prophylactic antiseptic mouth rinse followed by cleansing of the upper and lower lips with Povidone-Iodine cleansing solution. Lipstick application was done stepwise. Firstly the boundaries of the lips were marked with a red-colored (Lakme) lip liner to confine the lipstick application within the marked area. The tip of the lip liner was later cleansed with a cotton ball dipped in 'Pure Hands', a herbal hand cleanser, prior to using it on the next person. Lipstick was then uniformly applied with the help of a lipstick application brush in a systematic manner to avoid the smudging of the lipstick in the grooves. Once the application of the lipstick to one lip e.g. upper lip, was over, the subject was made to wait for 30 sec for drying of the lipstick. He or she was told to keep the teeth in occlusion and gently retract the opposing lip when the print of the concerned lip was being taken. Lip print was then obtained using 14-mm wide and 50-mm long Scotch tape with gentle pressure on either side. Since the human lips are so mobile that the strength or the direction of the pressure applied and even the minimal movement of the lip can affect the accuracy of the lip print taken, the subject was strictly advised not to change the position and avoid any movement of the lips during the procedure of recording the lip print. The Scotch tape was then stuck onto a plain white A4 size bond paper, with the details like the Serial No., the Name of the Subject and the Date of recording of the Lip Print mentioned on the page. The same procedure was then repeated to record the print of the lower lip. Recording of the upper and lower lip prints together was also done using Cellophane Tape (Width: 50 mm and Length: 50 mm), to aid in confirming the midline of the upper and the lower lip. Cleansing agent (Lakme) was used to clean the lips after the procedure. The used lipstick application brush was washed with water and the tips were immersed in diluted 0.5% Sodium Hypochlorite solution for 30 min and washed with water again prior to reuse. Each time while taking the lipstick with the application brush, a separate chemically sterilized brush was used in order to avoid the cross-contamination of the lipstick.
The lip print was then scanned (256 gray shades at a resolution of 300 dpi) for the digital analysis. Using various applications of Adobe Photoshop 7 software an attempt was made to trace each and every line. K. Suzuki and Y. Tsuchihashi's classification was followed to define the patterns of the grooves. , Strict criteria were followed to define Type II, III and IV pattern. While recording Type II pattern, only those lines that bifurcate, with the bifurcating lines not in the same straight line as the leg of the 'Y' were considered whereas lines showing trifurcation and multiple branching appearance were considered as Type V. Lines that intersect forming an 'X' pattern, without having any superimposition and the length of the arms of 'X' being almost equal from the point of intersection were considered as Type III pattern. Lines showing multiple interconnections and difficult to categorize in Type I to IV were directly considered as Type V. Each type of pattern was given a color code while recording it digitally as pink, blue, green, red, yellow and orange for Type I to V respectively.
Upper and lower lip print images were categorized into two quadrants each, thus producing a total of four quadrants. The four quadrants were named as follows: Upper Right as Quadrant I, Upper Left as Quadrant II, Lower Left as Quadrant III and Lower Right as Quadrant IV. Classified groove patterns were recorded by employing the dental formula generally used. Thus by noting the classified types of grooves, the individual's lip print pattern was recorded [Figure 1].
In each quadrant, the first 15 lines appearing from the midline to the periphery were recorded in 15 columns. Each pattern was given an Arabic numeral scoring in the following manner and as shown in [Table 1].Weighted values were given for the lip lines in the descending order from 15 to 1 with reference to their position from the midline. The product of the Arabic Numeral Score of the line and the weighted value of the line vis-à-vis its position from the midline was given as the lip line score. More weightage was given for the lines appearing in the center than at the periphery because this is the part of the lip which comes more in contact with any surface, and is the part often recorded without much distortion and smudging. By summing the weighted lip line score values, lip score in each quadrant for an individual subject was calculated. By adding the scores of all the four lip quadrants the LIP SCORE for each person was calculated to check for the uniqueness of the lip prints.
Subject and quadrant-wise display of lip scores including subject and upper lip (Quadrant I, II, I +II) and lower lip (Quadrant III, IV, III + IV) and total lip score for an individual (Lip scores of Quadrant I + II + III + IV) was also charted.
The same procedure was repeated after a one-year interval to evaluate the stability of the lip prints.
| Results|| |
It was observed that no two lip prints had exactly matching scores in all four quadrants. There were a number of cases where the lip score in a particular quadrant was the same but their lip scores in other quadrants differed and consequently so did their total lip score [Table 2]A-D and [Table 3].
|Table 2: - lip score in quadrants I, II, III, IV, I + II, III + IV, I + II + III + IV|
Click here to view
|Table 3: Subjects with the same lip score Quadrant I, II, III, IV, I + II, III + IV and I + II + III + IV.|
Click here to view
The total lip score i.e. Quadrant I + II + III + IV was unique for individual lips except for A - 70 and A - 74 having the score of 2352 and A - 77 and A - 80 sharing the same score of 2118 [Table 3].
Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test was used to check the stability of the lip prints over a period of time. No statistically significant difference was found in the change of pattern in lip print images collected after 12 months from the same individual, even after exposure of the lips to the seasonal variations and minor or superficial trauma.
The technique followed for collection of the lip prints using lipstick as a recording media and Scotch Tape as a transferring media provided clear and definable lip print image.
Digital method provided better visualization of the image and was convenient for analyzing the lip print pattern.
Various Type V patterns encountered in the current study included Cartwheel Appearance, Pineapple Skin Appearance, Trifurcations, Bridge or 'H' pattern, Horizontal Lines (predominantly found in the centre of the upper lip), and Multiple Branching Appearance (predominantly found at the lateral or peripheral aspect of the lower lip).
| Discussion|| |
Cheiloscopy (Quiloscopy) can be defined as a method of identification of a person based on the characteristic arrangement of lines appearing on the red part of lips, or as a science dealing with the lines appearing on the red part of lips.  It was first described by R. Fischer , in 1902. Since 1950 the Japanese have carried out extensive research in the matter. ,, Lip prints can be used with equal reliability in identification as fingerprints since it is claimed that no two individuals have identical lip prints. , Apart from identification and evidential use, lip prints may also be used in detection work, being the source of tactical and criminalistic information. A lip print at the scene of crime can be a basis for conclusions as to the character of the event, the number of the people involved, sexes, cosmetics used, habits, occupational traits, and the pathological changes of lips themselves.  Criminals make attempts to conceal their identity and try to destroy the finger skin pattern by self-inflicted wounds, by application of corrosives or by abrading the skin. These kinds of manipulations are unlikely to be inflicted by the criminals on their lips. Hence taking lip prints of all the suspected individuals and comparing them with the items found at the scene of crime could give conclusive evidence about the presence of a person at the crime scene. The other investigations become easier once the involvement of a suspect at the scene is confirmed.
Collection and recording of the lip prints
The lip crease pattern is on the vermilion border of the lip, which is quite mobile and lip prints may vary in appearance according to the pressure, direction and method used in making the print. If lipstick is used as a recording medium the amount applied may also affect the print. Hence a good method is required for the collection of the lip prints with suitable transferring and recording media. Various methods have been followed till today for recording the lip prints. ,,, The method that was preferred in the present study was using a Scotch tape.
The authors tried using cellophane tape, paper roller, dabbing of the lips against the paper and Scotch tape for recording the lip prints. Conventional powder method and photography were also tried. The lip prints are on the zone of transition of the lips which are extremely mobile. Smudging of the prints due to excessive or uneven pressure was noticed in subjects with prominent upper and/or lower lip when cellophane tape or paper roller was used to collect upper and lower lip print together. When the subject is asked to press his or her lips against the folded paper, there is a possibility of only the central area coming in contact with the paper and in doing so the rest or the relaxed position of the lips is not achieved which invariably leads to distortion of the prints. In conventional powder methods the brush tends to smear or leave streak marks on the print. These streak marks may then be interpreted as false characteristics by the comparer. Photographing of the lips was found to be very tricky and subject to errors as the central area of the lips and the angles of the lips are never in the same plane which leads to focusing errors resulting in blurred or partial images of the lips. This invariably calls for recording the lip prints and then photographing them and then comparing the two photographs. Thus in spite of being a reliable method in other areas of forensics, in the recording of lip print images it adds to the cost but does not enhance the clarity in the same rising proportions.
Since recording of the lip print becomes the fundamental exercise, the method adopted in the present study could be advantageous. Firstly, clear prints can be obtained including the peripheral grooves. Smaller width of the tape helps in its application along the curvature of the lip without any interference of the opposing lip (if properly retracted) and nose. Upper and lower lip print images can be recorded separately with minimal distortion in subjects having either one or both, upper-lower prominent lips or excess curvature of the lips. It is convenient to learn and easy to master the technique. The cost of the tape is also less.
Classification of the lip prints
The classification that was followed in the present study was Suzuki and Tsuchihashi's classification which is generally followed by most of the authors because of its accuracy and simplicity. Strict criteria were followed while considering all the types of patterns to avoid intra-observer bias. The authors would like to suggest some modifications with respect to the classification to make it more precise and accurate and standardize the readings of the various studies conducted by other workers in the country and elsewhere. This will help us in comparison of the various parameters in a greater sample size by following a standard classification. The following modifications are suggested, especially for Type I', Type II and Type V pattern. According to Suzuki and Tsuchihashi's classification Type I' is a straight groove that disappears halfway into the lip instead of covering the entire breadth of the lip. This pattern can be further classified into: Type I'A - A straight groove appearing from the outer margin of the lip to the inner aspect and Type I'B - A straight groove appearing from the inner margin of the lip to the outer aspect. Type II is grooves that fork or bifurcate in their course or a branched groove. This pattern can be further classified into: Type II A - grooves that bifurcate in the outward direction and Type II B-grooves that bifurcate in the inward direction. Type V-grooves that do not fall into any of the above categories and cannot be differentiated morphologically. Instead of just giving a generalized term as Type V pattern, it is found necessary to sub-classify the Type V pattern wherever possible, so as to give a more defined term that will further add to the accuracy of the classification. The current study reports six new patterns which are considered as Type V pattern.
Analysis of the lip prints
Various studies ,, have used magnifying lens to record lip prints. The current study has adopted an indirect digital method by scanning the lip print images in Adobe Photoshop 7 with 256 gray scale, 300 dpi resolution for better visualization of the image and recording each type of the groove patterns with assigned color code as mentioned thus ensuring the recording of each line without missing a single one and also eliminating an error of recording the same groove twice which is most likely to occur with manual recording.
The digital method adopted in the present study has various advantages due to its features like zooming, enhancement, layers and drawing tool. Adobe Photoshop is a popular software program, which allows for a multitude of imaging features, functions, enhancements and metric analysis. The initial working image can be enlarged using the zoom tool. The only limitation is the very high resolution of the image (300 dpi) required to avoid pixellation (fuzziness) of the magnified picture. Regardless of the method by which an image is captured, once it has been digitized, several computerized enhancements can be performed on the image. Brightness and contrast can both be altered. This gives us the chance to "salvage" an image that is either too dark or too light. There is a limit to the ability of salvaging poor images. An image in which all of the pixels have been saturated (too dark) or where the noise (useless information) in the system overwhelms the signal (useful information), cannot be saved. Image contrast can also be manipulated by altering the gradient of the gray levels in the image. Again, there is a limit to how much contrast can be altered. Manipulating the image contrast cannot salvage an image in which the subject contrast is inadequate. With layers, we can work on one element without disturbing others. To rearrange elements, simply shift the order in the layers palette. We can lock layers to prevent accidental changes, hide them to get a clear view of the element we are working on, and link layers to move them as a group. The layers palette also makes it easy to apply instant, editable effects including blending modes, adjustment layers, and layer effects. Resolution-independent vector shapes can be drawn instantly with the line, rectangle, ellipse, polygon, and custom shape tools. This method also has certain disadvantages.
Direct digital imaging indicates that the original image is captured in a digital format, i.e., the image is made up of discrete packets of information called pixels (picture elements).On the other hand, indirect digital imaging implies that the image is captured in an analog or continuous format and then converted into a digital format. As with any data conversion, this analog to digital conversion (ADC) results in the loss and alteration of information. Instead of capturing the border that traverses a particular pixel, the pixel value is averaged. This is called partial volume averaging. Consequently, many edges are lost or distorted in an analog to digital conversion.
Total recorded lip lines
Sivapathasundharam B. and Prakash P. A.  have taken the middle part of the lower lip, (10-mm wide) as a study area, since this fragment is almost always visible in any trace.
The current study has made an attempt to record each and every line of the entire lip starting from the midline to the periphery. In some subjects, the lip lines were very clear and were easily identified but in some lips only a few lines could be recorded and in others, the lines were not identifiable because of the poor quality of the image. The number of the lines recorded quadrant-wise is shown in detail in [Table 4]. With the help of digital analysis, up to 15 lines were traceable in 66% of Quadrant I, 71% of Quadrant II, 52% of Quadrant III and 51% of Quadrant IV images. The reason for some of the images showing very few or non-recordable lines can be attributed to the inherent anatomy of the lips, technical error and processing error. Thin lips, recessive lips, inverted lips, excessive prominence either in the center or lateral portion of the lips, excessive curvature of the lips, fine groove pattern on the lips, all these factors can affect the quality of the lip print image. The lips are two highly mobile fleshy folds surrounding the orifice of the mouth. The anatomy of the lips varies from person to person. They may be full or thin, wide or narrow, short or long, generally in response to genetic data and the form of the teeth. The inclination of the teeth may cause the lips to be excessively prominent or recessive. In the edentulous person the lips recede, increasing the prominence of the nose and chin, since the inter-arch distance may be reduced and the nose and chin tend to approximate each other. With thin, recessive and inverted lips it is difficult to record the lip print using any of the above methods. Excessive prominence in any part of the lips or excessive curvature of the lips leads to pressure areas resulting in distortion of the image. In such cases a compromise has to be made over the lateral areas so as to clearly record the central area with minimal pressure. With fine groove pattern on the lips, there is all possibility of excess lipstick getting smudged in the grooves resulting in a distorted image.
Excessive application of the lipstick leads to smudging of lipstick in the grooves and thus unclear groove pattern. Lips being highly mobile, minimal variation in the pressure application while recording the lip print using Scotch tape or any other method can lead to distortion of the image. Variation in the posture of the lip i.e. contraction or stretching of the lips during the procedure of recording can either lead to overlapping of the grooves or clear area without any groove pattern, thus causing distortion of the image.
Mobility of the lips is nature's creation, and an error caused because of this nature of the lips could not be avoided. But an effort was made to minimize the technical error and to standardize the technique of recording the lip prints. For uniform application of the lipstick, a lipstick application brush was used with vertical strokes of the brush starting from the outer to the inner aspect of the lip. Care was taken to evenly apply the pressure while recording the lip prints with Scotch tape. For standardizing the posture of the lips while recording, the subject was advised to keep his/her teeth in occlusion and lips relaxed and strict instructions were given to stabilize this posture during the procedure of recording the lip print. A set of images were recorded and the image with minimal distortion and clear groove pattern was selected for analysis.
Processing errors are the errors expected to occur in Indirect or Scanned Digital Method as described above. The data loss that occurs due to the averaged pixel value in an analog to digital conversion leads to decreased contrast between the creases (white areas) and the ridges (dark areas) and thus may lead to a decreased contrast or an image with minimal recordable grooves.
Uniqueness of the lip prints
No two lip prints were found to have similar characteristics which was in agreement with the previous studies reported. , The combination of the six types of grooves is, theoretically, 6 6 X 4, and if they are entered in the dental formula the advisable method is to select the first groove from the median line, and then, focusing on the chief construction of the second group of grooves, to compare the peculiarities and the details with the control. 
To determine the uniqueness, the current study adopted a scoring method wherein weighted value in descending order from 15 to 1 was given for the lip lines starting from the midline to the periphery. Total lip score for each quadrant i.e. Quadrant I, II, III, and IV was then calculated along with the score of the individual lips i.e. Quadrant I + II, Quadrant III + IV and the total score of the lip i.e. Quadrant I + II + III + IV. These scores were then compared to check the uniqueness of the individual lip prints.
It was found that the total lip score i.e. Quadrant I + II + III + IV was unique for individual lips except for A-70 and A-74 having the score of 2352 and A-77 and A-80 sharing the same score of 2118. Although the total lip score in above cases was matching, they differed in the individual quadrant score viz. scores of A-70 in Quadrant I - 618, Quadrant II - 642, Quadrant I + II - 1260, Quadrant III - 542, Quadrant IV - 550 and in Quadrant III + IV - 1092 whereas scores of A-74 in Quadrant I - 702, Quadrant II - 450, Quadrant I + II - 1152, Quadrant III - 627, Quadrant IV - 573 and in Quadrant III + IV - 1200. Scores of A -77 in Quadrant I - 435, Quadrant II - 522, Quadrant I + II - 957, Quadrant III - 684, Quadrant IV - 477 and in Quadrant III + IV - 1161 whereas scores of A-80 in Quadrant I - 714, Quadrant II - 645, Quadrant I + II - 1359, Quadrant III - 375, Quadrant IV - 384 and in Quadrant III + IV - 759.
There were a number of cases where the lip score in a particular quadrant was the same but their lip scores in other quadrants differed and consequently so did their total lip score [Table 2] and [Table 3].
It was observed that no two lip prints had exactly matching scores in all four Quadrants. The scores were differing either in the individual Quadrants i.e. I, II, III or IV or in the sum of the two Quadrants I + II or III + IV or in total lip score i.e. Quadrant I + II + III + IV.
Our method appears to settle once and for all the question of uniqueness of the lip print as it employs whole numbers and thereby is an open-ended method since the last 'whole number is yet to be written, whole numbers being infinite'. Thus each individual is assured with his or her own lip identity card number!
Stability of the lip prints
Injuries to the skin, such as cuts, burns and abrasions, may affect the alignment of ridges and may even result in the destruction of some. Superficial injuries cause only temporary damage; on healing, the patterns and details of the ridges appear as before. When, however, the skin is injured causing destruction of the dermal papillae, scars are formed which result in permanent distortion of the ridges. 
However, the author has not come across any such detailed studies being done on the lips. Histologically the lip can be divided into three parts, outer skin of the lip that consists of keratinized stratified squamous epithelium in which hair follicles, sweat glands and sebaceous glands can be seen, the vermilion border or the red margin of the lip which is very thin keratinized epithelium with no hair follicles or sweat glands and the submucosa of the lip, composed of dense connective tissue containing blood vessels, nerves and mixed seromucous glands. Being an intermediate zone, the lip is composed of the histologic features of the skin as well as the oral mucosa. Healing response depends upon the depth of the wounds even in the case of lips. But whether the destruction of the dermal papillae leads to scar formation in lips like in the case of skin cannot be said with certainty. Also, the depth of injuries leading to scar formation in lips is yet to be investigated. TsuchihashiY  studied lip prints by recording them routinely once a month for three years for comparative study. No change was observed during this time. The author also studied the samples of the lip prints of the same individual taken at six-monthly intervals. He has illustrated the serial observations made on the lip print every day (except Sundays and holidays) for nine weeks which revealed no changes.
Vahanwala S. P. and Parekh B. K.  confirmed that the labial wrinkles and grooves of each individual were identical with the ones taken four months earlier.
To determine the stability of the lip prints, the current study collected the lip prints 12 months (Part B) after the initial collection (Part A). An interval of 12 months was kept to check the effect of any seasonal variation or healing response of the lips to inflammation on the groove pattern if present. None of the subjects gave history of any deep injuries to the lips, but there was history of cracking or chapping of the lips in the winter.
Lip print images of all the subjects were collected after 12 months in a similar manner as in Part A. Nine subjects dropped out of the study, hence their lip prints could not be recorded. The author has considered equal number of lines for comparison of Part A and Part B of the study. Using Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test, each line in Part A was compared to that of Part B for determining any statistically significant changes in the groove pattern that had occurred after 12 months. The statistical results of comparison showed no significant changes in the first 15 lines in all four quadrants in a study repeated after one year.
Further studies are required to be carried out on a larger population to evaluate the uniqueness using the digital method for analyzing the lip prints. Studies in the field of healing pattern and the effect of deep injuries over the groove pattern on the lips are recommended.
| Conclusions|| |
The following conclusions can be drawn from the observations of the current study:
Lip prints are unique to the individual which can be explained on the basis that no two individuals in the studied group had an exactly matching lip score in all four quadrants.
Lip prints remain stable over a period of time. No statistically significant difference was found in the change of pattern in lip print images collected after 12 months from the same individual, even after exposure of the lips to the seasonal variations and minor or superficial trauma.
Thus from the above statements, it can be concluded that lip prints can be used as an evidence or a positive means of person identification just like fingerprints.
The technique followed for collection of the lip prints using lipstick as recording media and Scotch tape as transferring media with proper stabilization of the lips while recording can be adopted as a good technique to obtain a definable lip print image.
The digital method of analyzing the lip print images using Adobe Photoshop 7 software serves as a convenient method that provides better visualization and ease in recording and identification of the lip print pattern. It also serves as an ideal method of permanently storing the data which will help in keeping an ante- mortem record of an individual.
Weighted Value Scoring system used for the first time to calculate the lip score (quadrant-wise, lip-wise, and the total score), appears to settle once and for all the question of the uniqueness of the lip print as it employs whole numbers and thereby is an open-ended method since the last 'whole number is yet to be written, whole numbers being infinite'.
| References|| |
|1.||Suzuki K, Tsuchihashi Y. A New Attempt of Personal Identification by Means of Lip Print. Canadian Soc Forensic Sci 1971;4:154-58. |
|2.||Suzuki K, Tsuchihashi Y. New Attempt of Personal Identification by Means of Lip Print. J Indian Dent Assoc 1970;42:8-9. |
|3.||Suzuki K, Tsuchihashi Y. Personal Identification by Means of Lip Prints. J Forensic Med 1970;17:52-7. |
|4.||Vahanwala SP, Parekh BK. Study of lip prints as an aid to forensic methodology. J Forensic Med Toxicol 2000;17:12-8. |
|5.||Sivapathasundharam B, Prakash PA, Sivakumar G. Lip Prints (Cheiloscopy). Indian J Dent Res 2001;12:234-7. |
|6.||Varghese AJ, Somesekar M, Babu UR. A study on Lip prints types among the people of kerala. J Indian Acad Forensic Med 2010;32:6-7 |
|7.||Saraswati TR, Mishra G, Ranganathan K. Study of Lip prints. J Forensic Dent Sci 2009;1:28-31. |
|8.||Sharma P, Saxena S, Rathod V. Cheiloscopy: The study of lip prints in sex identification. JForensic Dent Sci 2009;1:24-7. |
|9.||Gondivkar SM, Indurkar A, Degwekar S, Bhowate R. Cheiloscopy for sex determination. JForensic Dent Sci 2009;1:56-60. |
|10.||Kasprzak J. Possibilities of Cheiloscopy. Forensic SciInt 1990;46:145-51. |
|11.||Kasprzak J. Cheiloscopy. In: Encyclopedia of Forensic Sciences. In:Siegal JA, Saukko PJ., Knupfer GC (editors). 2nd edi, Vol I. London: Academic Press, 2000: 358-61. |
|12.||Prabhu R, Dinkar A, Prabhu V. Collection of Lip prints as forensic evidence at the crime scene - An insight. J Oral Health Res 2010;1:129-35 |
|13.||Tsuchihashi Y. Studies on Personal Identification by Means of Lip Prints. Forensic Sci 1974;3:233-48. |
|14.||Holt SB. Ridged skin. In: The Genetics of Dermal Ridges. In: Kugelmass N (editors). Springfield, Illinois, U.S.A:Thomas CC. Publisher;.1968. p.5-11. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]