|Year : 2018 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 18-21
Validation of the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell tooth wear chart, using skulls of known age at death
Ibrahim Alayan1, Mohammed S Aldossary2, Ario Santini3
1 Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Zliten Dental School, Al-Asmarya Islamic University, Zliten, Libya
2 Department of Dentistry, Ministry of Health, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
3 Department of General and Inorganic Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, The University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Targu Mures, Romania; Edinburgh Dental Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK
|Date of Web Publication||27-Jul-2018|
Mohammed S Aldossary
P.O. Box: 13743, Riyadh 11414
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Objective: The present study aims to validate the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell tooth wear chart, uniquely using skulls of recorded known age at death. Materials and Methods: Fifty Chinese skulls, of known age recorded at death, ranging from 16 to 62 years, were used. All the skulls were anonymized laid out, numbered 1–50, and using randomized tables. A 70-mm, ×3 magnification glass with light (Rolson, Ruscombe, Twyford, Berkshire, United Kingdom) was used to evaluate tooth wear patterns, and the age assessed using newly devised “age calculator” based on the Brothwell Chart. Results: The recorded age at death versus the estimated age derived from the Brothwell chart was statistically compared the weighted kappa score = 0.877, suggestive of a “very good” strength of agreement. Conclusion: The Brothwell chart, based on tooth wear, can be used as a consistent method of age assessment, allowing for easier and more rapid data collection with no loss of overall accuracy.
Keywords: Age estimation, Brothwell chart, forensic odontology, forensic science, tooth wear
|How to cite this article:|
Alayan I, Aldossary MS, Santini A. Validation of the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell tooth wear chart, using skulls of known age at death. J Forensic Dent Sci 2018;10:18-21
|How to cite this URL:|
Alayan I, Aldossary MS, Santini A. Validation of the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell tooth wear chart, using skulls of known age at death. J Forensic Dent Sci [serial online] 2018 [cited 2018 Dec 18];10:18-21. Available from: http://www.jfds.org/text.asp?2018/10/1/18/237775
| Introduction|| |
Age estimation is critical in forensic medicine for identification purposes of deceased victims and missing persons and in the context of felonies and accidents. Various methods have been proposed for age assessment. Chronological age estimation in children based on dental maturation may be divided into those using the Atlas More Details approach and those using scoring systems and can be obtained with relative accuracy, based on the order and time of tooth eruption from infancy to about 21 years of age. Tooth mineralization stages are much less affected by variation in nutritional and endocrine status and developing teeth and therefore provide a relatively accurate indication of chronological age, and that difference in eruption times varies according to inherent biological variability, more controlled by genes than by environmental factors.
Schour and Massler  used data obtained by Logan and Kronfeld  compiled two charts showing schematically, the development of the human dentition. The information in tables has been extensively used over the years and has proved to be relatively accurate in spite of the medically compromised small sample size which was derived from 25 postmortem specimens of which 19 were under 2 years of age.
More precise and detailed techniques of age estimation have been published.,,,, However, these methods involve time-consuming and cost-inefficient techniques after tooth extraction and preparation of microscopic sections of teeth or time-consuming radiographic observation following obtaining ethical approval.
The age assessment of individuals of 28 years and older is more challenging. Morphological techniques  or radiology techniques , are based on the measurement of regressive changes in teeth including factors such as the loss of periodontal attachment, the apposition of cementum at the root apex, the amount of apical resorption, and the transparency of the root. Again, their weakness is in the time-consuming nature of data collection.
Tooth wear patterns have been used for many years as an age estimation scheme, in spite of early acceptance that tooth wear patterns are not solely a function of age, being significantly influenced by certain kinds of food, the method of mastication, existence of artificial teeth, gender, geographic location, environmental conditions, and parafunction., Most of the schemes, which assess age by tooth wear, first compile a group of young children and adults of “known age” determined from eruption patterns.
Many studies have reported on age assessment by wear scores,,, and a considerable number used the Miles method.,,,,
The lack of a suitable known-age reference cohorts from which to age past populations is one of the biggest problems in dental wear aging, and tooth wear patterns appraised in one population should not be used to assess age in another population or era.,, Millard and Gowland, using a version of the Miles method, reported older ages than traditional methods, especially in individuals showing heavy degrees of tooth wear patterns.
Kim et al. opined that scoring tooth wear was a very accurately method for placing subjects into two age groups. Brothwell's method, based firmly on Miles, constrained age assessment to three age groups, rather than the continuum as used by Miles. The Brothwell chart is user-friendly and quick to use. It, however, requires the data to be validated against skulls of recorded known age and not against those whose “known age” has been extrapolated forward from a cohort assessed by tooth eruption.
The aim of this study is to validate the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell tooth wear chart, using skulls of known age at death.
| Materials and Methods|| |
Preliminary study: Intra- and inter-observer reliability
Intra- and inter-observer reliability was first assessed in the following way.
For intra-observer reliability, ten mandibles showing different wear patterns and not used in the main study were chosen by a university staff member not involved in data collection. The museum identification marks were obscured by wrapping the mandible in tin foil so that only the occlusal surfaces of the teeth were visible. Using randomized tables, the mandibles were then placed on the examination table ordered from 1 to 10.
The wear patterns on the mandibular first and second molars were recorded using the Brothwell chart. This was designated as Sequence A. After a period of 3 weeks, the same skulls were arranged using randomized tables, in a different sequence, designated as Sequence B. Wear patterns for Sequence A and B were then compared. This was repeated until a high agreement was achieved between sequences. Inter-observer reliability was assessed in a similar manner.
Ten different skulls were chosen by a university staff member not involved in data collection. This time the wear patterns on mandibular first and second molars were recorded by two observers, the author plus one other. The two sets of scores were then compared. Three weeks later, the same skulls were arranged in a different sequence using the randomized tables, and scores were taken. Scores recorded by the two observers were repeated until a high level of agreement was achieved between sequences.
Main Study: Validation the efficacy of age assessment by the Brothwell chart
An independent colleague randomly chose fifty mandibles from Chinese skulls of known age from the Turner Collection, Anatomy Section, Department of Biomedical Sciences in the College of Medicine, University of Edinburgh. The age at death of each of the Chinese skulls was known, having been recorded at the time of acquisition. The age range was from 16 to 62 years. In attestation of this, the collector stated that “the age of each individual was noted at death and the age, sex, and nationality are beyond doubt.”
All the skulls had an identification mark placed at the time of deposition of the skulls in the museum, and this matched the recorded date at death. A colleague obscured all these identification marks on the skulls by wrapping the mandible in tin foil so that only the teeth occlusal surfaces were visible. The skulls were then laid out, numbered 1–50, using randomized tables. The mandibular teeth were cleaned with nonalcoholic material to make sure that all details of wear were clear. A handheld 70-mm Magnifying Glass with Light, ×3 magnification (Rolson, Ruscombe, Twyford, Berkshire, United Kingdom), was used to evaluate tooth wear patterns.
A newly devised “age calculator” was used, based on the Brothwell Chart. This “tool” consists of:
- One blank record card [Figure 1] for each of the 50 teeth. On this card, the sequence number was recorded as well as the (eventual) estimated age
There are diagrams of two blank teeth (occlusal surfaces) on which the tooth wear patterns are drawn. On the right side, there is an aid to show the colors used to illustrate the patterns and spaces for the skull number and actual age, to be filled in at the end of the exercise. During the assessment, these are blank
- A transparent sheet, with a vertical red line, can be placed over the completed record card. In the illustration [Figure 2], the red line has been aligned with M1
- The Brothwell chart was put between the record card and the transparent sheet. This is moved horizontally until the registered wear pattern on the record card corresponds with a similar pattern on the Brothwell chart.
In the original Brothwell chart, patterns for M3 are also given. M3 was not used in this study.
The wear patterns of M1 and M2 for each tooth are recorded on the record card in the appropriate boxes. The transparent sheet is overlaid and the chart inserted between the two. The chart is moved until the recorded pattern corresponded with a similar pattern on the Brothwell chart. When there was doubt about the tooth wear patterns, the age was always assessed upward. This process was repeated for M2. Only after all the 50 records were complete, the skull number and actual age were filled in the record card by the colleague.
“Weighted kappa,” quantifying inter- and intra-rater agreements, was calculated using GraphPad QuickCalcs website: http://www.graphpad.com/quickcalcs/kappa1/cfm.
| Results|| |
[Table 1] gives the results of the intra- and inter-observer reliability for both the first molar tooth (M1) and the second molar tooth (M2) together with weighted kappa score showing the strength of agreement. This was deemed to be “very good” for both teeth.
[Table 2] shows the recorded age at death versus the estimated age derived from the Brothwell chart. The number of observed agreements was 44 (88.00% of the observations); the number of agreements expected by chance was 15.6 (31.28% of the observations). The weighted kappa score = 0.877, suggestive of “very good” strength of agreement.
|Table 2: Recorded age at death versus estimated age from Brothwell chart|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Many previous studies of adult age assessment by tooth wear have used materials in which age has been assessed indirectly and not from authenticated records. Essentially, the current study is a validation of the Miles method, on which Brothwell based his chart. Miles estimated the age of each skull by reference to a group of younger skulls whose age was determined from tooth eruption information. The current study differs in that a substantial number of skulls, of confirmed known age, were used. They were then blindly assessed for age using the Brothwell tooth wear chart.
Weighted kappa was used to calculate the inter-rater agreement statistic between two measurements as weighted kappa determines the agreement when the rating is done on categorized or ranked order information rather than continued information. Close matching was always achieved. Skulls were always allocated either to the correct age group (most cases) or an adjacent group but never to a group nonadjacent.
The strength of agreement between the actual age group and estimated age group was considered to be good. It has been argued that the accuracy of age estimation was increased , if skulls were categorized into age groups rather than given a “specific age,” and the above results are in general agreement with this.
In spite of these promising results, forensic odontologists should not restrict assessments to one particular technique. It is advisable to employ the different techniques and repetitive measurements. The Brothwell chart should be viewed as a non-time-consuming, user-friendly screening method well suited for assessments of a vast number of cases.
| Conclusion|| |
The intra- and inter-observer reliability testing indicated that tooth wear assessment at different periods and between the various assessors was precise to the extent that it could be used in age assessment methods.
The Brothwell chart, based on tooth wear, can be used as a reasonable method of age assessment, allowing for easier and more rapid data collection with no loss of overall accuracy.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Willems G. A review of the most commonly used dental age estimation techniques. J Forensic Odontostomatol 2001;19:9-17.
Maled V, Manjunatha B, Patil K, Balaraj BM. The chronology of third molar root mineralization in South Indian population. Med Sci Law 2014;54:28-34.
Schour I, Massler M. The development of the human dentition. J Am Dent Assoc 1941;28:1153-60.
Logan WH, Kronfeld R. Development of the human jaws and surrounding structures from birth to the age of fifteen years. J Am Dent Assoc 1933;20:379-428.
Gustafson G. Age determination on teeth. J Am Dent Assoc 1950;41:45-54.
Gleiser I, Hunt EE Jr., The permanent mandibular first molar: Its calcification, eruption and decay. Am J Phys Anthropol 1955;13:253-83.
Demirjian A, Goldstein H, Tanner JM. A new system of dental age assessment. Hum Biol 1973;45:211-27.
Moorrees CF, Fanning EA, Hunt EE Jr. Age variation of formation stages for ten permanent teeth. J Dent Res 1963;42:1490-502.
Anderson DL, Thompson GW, Popovich F. Age of attainment of mineralization stages of the permanent dentition. J Forensic Sci 1976;21:191-200.
Brooks ST. Skeletal age at death: The reliability of cranial and pubic age indicators. Am J Phys Anthropol 1955;13:567-97.
Solheim T. A new method for dental age estimation in adults. Forensic Sci Int 1993;59:137-47.
Kvaal SI, Kolltveit KM, Thomsen IO, Solheim T. Age estimation of adults from dental radiographs. Forensic Sci Int 1995;74:175-85.
Reeder WG. Age variation in enamel patterns in the spiny pocket mouse, liomys pictus sonoranus. J Mammal 1953;34:59-64.
Telang LA, Patil K, Mahima VG. Age estimation of an indian population by using the Kim's scoring system of occlusal tooth wear. J Forensic Dent Sci 2014;6:16-24.
] [Full text]
Miles AE. Assessment of the ages of a population of anglo-saxons from their dentitions. Proc R Soc Med 1962;55:881-6.
Marston AT. Comments on the solution of the piltdown problem. Proc R Soc Med 1954;47:100-2.
Hojo M. On the pattern of the dental abrasion. Okajimas Folia Anat Jpn 1954;26:11-30.
Murphy T. The changing pattern of dentine exposure in human tooth attrition. Am J Phys Anthropol 1959;17:167-78.
Miles AE. The assessment of age from the dentition. Proc R Soc Med 1958;51:1057-60.
Nowell GW. An evaluation of the miles method of ageing using the tepe hissar dental sample. Am J Phys Anthropol 1978;49:271-6.
Brothwell DR. Digging up Bones: The Excavation, Treatment, and Study of Human Skeletal Remains. 3rd
ed. New York: Cornell University Press; 1981.
Kieser JA, Preston CB, Evans WG. Skeletal age at death: An evaluation of the miles method of ageing. J Archaeol Sci 1983;10:9-12.
Johnson JS. A comparison of age estimation using discriminant function analysis with some other age estimations of unknown skulls. J Anat 1976;121:475-84.
Millard A, Gowland R. A Bayesian approach to the estimation of the age of humans from tooth development and wear. Archeologia e Calcolatori 2002;13:197-210.
Kim YK, Kho HS, Lee KH. Age estimation by occlusal tooth wear. J Forensic Sci 2000;45:303-9.
Harrower G. A biometric study of one hundred and ten Asiatic mandibles. Biometrika 1928;20:279-93.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
[Table 1], [Table 2]